Comparison of Breakdown Voltage and Aging of Kraft Paper in Transformers Immersed in Mineral Oil, Natural Ester, and Synthetic Ester
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51747/energy.v15i2.15215Keywords:
Mineral Oil, Natural Ester, Synthetic Ester, Tensile Strength, Water Content, Breakdown VoltageAbstract
Transformers are critical components in electrical power systems that rely on insulation oil and paper to ensure reliable and long-lasting operation. This study aims to compare the performance of kraft insulation paper immersed in three types of transformer oil, namely mineral oil, natural ester, and synthetic ester, through the accelerated thermal aging method. Evaluation was carried out based on tensile strength and water content testing in accordance with the IEEE C57.100-2011 standard, as well as breakdown voltage testing in accordance with the IEC 60156-2018 standard. Tests were conducted with samples taken at intervals of 24, 240, 480, and 720 hours at 150°C. The results showed that insulation paper soaked in mineral oil experienced a 34% decrease in tensile strength, while natural ester and synthetic ester oils showed tensile strengths of 66% and 52%, respectively. In the water content test, natural ester showed the best performance with the lowest water content (5.19%), followed by mineral oil (7.47%) and synthetic ester (46.70%). In the breakdown voltage test, natural ester had the highest breakdown voltage of 66.26 kV, followed by mineral oil at 63.96 kV and synthetic ester at 41.14 kV. Estimated insulation life based on lifetime regression showed that natural ester has a lifetime of up to 37.9 years, synthetic ester 25.6 years, and mineral oil 20.5 years. In addition, in transformers operating at 130°C, natural ester insulation oil can increase loading up to 20% higher than mineral oil and has a 15-20°C higher operating temperature. This study recommends the use of kraft insulation paper impregnated with natural ester and synthetic ester oils as an alternative to mineral oil, because both are superior environmentally friendly alternatives compared to mineral oil. Both oils have better mechanical strength and insulation, lower water content, and can slow down transformer aging. Furthermore, these ester oils are non-flammable, biodegradable, and reduce the risk of failure due to excessive heat or discharge, thereby increasing the reliability and lifespan of the transformer. With these properties, ester oils support safer and more sustainable operations for the power system.
References
[1] A. Indarto, A. Bohra, S. Wahyudi, dan A. Dharmanto, “Trafo daya menggunakan minyak isolasi yang dapat terurai secara biologis,” Hexatech J. Ilm. Tek., vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 49–55, 2023.
[2] J. Jumardin, J. Ilham, dan S. Salim, “Studi Karakteristik Minyak Nilam Sebagai Alternatif Pengganti Minyak Transformator,” Jambura J. Electr. Electron. Eng., vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 40–48, 2019.
[3] PT. PLN (Persero), “Buku Pedoman Trafo Tenaga,” Buku Pedoman Pemeliharaan Trafo Tenaga, pp. 1–142, 2014.
[4] G. R. K. Anggara, S. Prasetyono, dan R. M. Gozali, “Analisis Karakteristik Dielektrik Berbagai Minyak Nabati Sebagai Alternatif Isolasi Cair Untuk Transformator Tenaga,” Jurnal Arus Elektro Indonesia, vol. 8, no. 1. pp. 1, 2022.
[5] M. Srivastava, S. K. Goyal, dan A. Saraswat, “Ester oil as an alternative to mineral transformer insulating liquid,” in ELSEVIER, 2021, pp. 2850–2854.
[6] J. Jacob, P. Preetha, dan S. T. Krishnan, “Review on natural ester and nanofluids as an environmental friendly alternative to transformer mineral oil,” IET Nanodielectrics, vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 33–43, 2020.
[7] IEEE Std C57.155, IEEE Std C57.155. IEEE Guide for Interpretation of Gases Generated in Natural Ester and Synthetic Ester-Immersed Transformers IEEE Power and Energy Society. 2014.
[8] Duanaputri, Prasojo, Wiwaha, et al., "Pengembangan Uji Eksperimental Penuaan Dipercepat Sistem Isolasi Kertas Terendam Minyak Transformator," Elposys J. Sist. Kelistrikan, vol. 10, no. 3, pp. 142–145, 2023.
[9] R. A. Prasojo et al., “Evaluasi Kinerja Sistem Isolasi Transformator Kertas Kraft Terendam Minyak Mineral Pada Sel Uji Penuaan Termal Dipercepat,” Elposys J. Sist. Kelistrikan, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 87–92, 2023.
[10] CIGRE 323, Ageing of Cellulose in Mineral-Oil Insulated Transformers. 2007.
[11] IEC TS 62332-2, Electrical insulation systems (EIS) : thermal evaluation of combined liquid and solid components. Part 2, Simplified test. 2011.
[12] IEC 60076-1, Power Transformers - Part 1: General, vol. 2011. 2011.
[13] M. Tohari, B. Sukoco, dan M. Haddin, “Analisis Kondisi Transformator Daya 20Kv/150Kv Dengan Metode Uji Dissolved Gas Analysis (Dga) Di Pt.Pjb Pltu Rembang,” Konf. Ilm. Mhs. Unissula 4, pp. 337–344, 2020.
[14] M. Ahmad, I. Daris, H. Rahmat, dan S. Suwarno, “Aging Behavior of Mineral Oil, Gas-to-Liquid (GTL), and Natural Ester Liquids in Presence of Cellulosic Materials,” 2021 3rd Int. Conf. High Volt. Eng. Power Syst. ICHVEPS 2021, pp. 501–506, 2021.
[15] CIGRE 761, Power Transformers and Reactors. 2019.
[16] S. R. Arsad et al., “Water Content in Transformer Insulation System: A Review on the Detection and Quantification Methods,” Energies, vol. 16, no. 4, 2023.
[17] IEEE C57100, IEEE Standard Test Procedure for Thermal Evaluation of Liquid-Immersed Distribution and Power Transformers, vol. 1999, no. January. 2011.
[18] R. Duanaputri, R. A. Prasojo, D. Wiranti, S. S. Wiwaha, D. N. Akbar, dan G. P. C. Handani, “Analysis and Experiments of Insulation Loss of Transformer Kraft Paper Based on Hotspot Variations,” Int. J. Electr. Eng. Appl. Sci., vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 29–34, 2023.
[19] Wiley, Transformers Ageing. 2017. [Daring]. Available at: https://www.google.co.id/books/edition/Transformer_Ageing/tkkzDwAAQBAJ?hl=id&gbpv=1&dq=natural+ester+oil&pg=PA377&printsec=frontcover
[20] A. Syakur dan W. Lazuardi, “Penerapan Metode Interpretasi Rasio Roger, Segitiga Duval, Breakdown Test, dan Water Content Test untuk Diagnosis Kelayakan Minyak Transformator,” Teknik, vol. 40, pp. 1, hal. 63–68, 2019.
[21] H. D. F. Amaral et al. 2024. “Karakteristik Tegangan tembus Pada Dielektrik Minyak Mineral Dan Minyak Ester Natural.” Elposys J. Sist. Kelistrikan, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 179–183, 2024.
[22] CIGRE WG A2.18, Guide For Life Management Techniques For Power Transformer. 2003
[23] Gasser, Hans Peter, Christoph Krause, Mark Lashbrook, dan Russel Martin. 2011. “Aging of pressboard in different insulating liquids.” Proceedings - IEEE International Conference on Dielectric Liquids, 1–5. https://doi.org/10.1109/ICDL.2011.6015450.
[24] Dielectric Properties of Ester alami, Synthetic Ester Midel 7131, and Mineral Oil Diala D (June, 2012). IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation, 19(3), 827-834.
[25] Jayyid, U. L. (2024). Studi Komparasi Minyak Mineral, Sintetik Ester, Dan Natural Ester Sebagai Isolasi Cair Pada Transformator. 23222368.
[26] M. Rafiq et al. 2020. “Sustainable, Renewable and Environmental-Friendly Insulation Systems for High Voltages Applications.” Molecules, 25, 3901; doi:10.3390/molecules25173901
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 ENERGY: JURNAL ILMIAH ILMU-ILMU TEKNIK
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
